Arbitrations/a20100714.1

Before: Arbitrator UlrichSchroeter (A), Respondent: CAcert (R), Claimant: Jochen B (C), Case: a20100714.1

History Log

2010-07-14 (issue.c.o) case [s20100714.184, s20100714.185, s20100714.186]
2010-07-16 (iCM): added to wiki, request for CM / A
2011-04-09 (A): I'll take care about this case as (A)
2011-04-09 (A): I appoint the (CM) as per Arbitration Team meeting 2011-04-05 decision
2011-04-09 (A): sending initmailing to (C) with CCA/DRP acceptance request
2011-04-10 (C): is it possible to remove my middlename ? - no CCA/DRP acceptance yet
2011-04-10 (A): re-requesting CCA/DRP acceptance from (C)
2011-04-10 (C): confirms CCA/DRP acceptance
2011-04-11 (A): request to (Support), list of names on (C)'s account
2011-04-11 (Support): [s20110410.76] listed name fields, 1 Givenname + 1 Middlename exists

case can be handled by similiar case a20100227.1 "Small modification in username + Account Cleanup (Dirk R) - Precedents Case {i}" Part I ruling
Removal of Middlename doesn't conflicts with PracticeOnNames. No assurances are effected. So can be passed w/o further investigations if the requirements are fulfilled:
- At least one Givenname is still left in users account w/o abbreviations - this is given by users Givenname
- a request, to revoke affected Client certs, that contains the removed name part, and that were issued after 2009-11-08

by following the precedents case a20100227.1 I hereby rule, that (Support) should remove the users Middlename as requested. This execution doesn't conflict with AP nor PracticeOnNames. No assurances given are effected, as the simple rule states
```
For names or name parts:
   * in general: its allowed to reduce information, but it is prohibited to add informations
```
(Support) should also execute the revocation of client certs as given by the ruling under a20100227.1 part I, the user has to revoke client certs with the removed Middlename in it, that were issued after 2009-11-08, by requesting a statement from the user that he revoked affected client certs with a CARS statement and to document the response within the Support ticket.
The Arbitration case number to add to the Support ticket is the current arbitration case number a20100714.1, nu further exec report to the Arbitrator is needed.

Frankfurt/Main, 2011-04-11

2011-04-11 (A): sending ruling and exec order to (Support), (C), (CM). Case Closed.

a20090618.8	User has non-validated middle name in account
a20090618.11	User wishes to remove middle names
a20091231.1	unverified middle name in account
a20100103.1	unverified middle name in account
a20100227.1	Small modification in username + Account Cleanup (Dirk R) - Precedents Case