- Case Number: a20100314.1
- Status: closed
- Claimants: Michael T, Andreas A, Dominik G, Bjoern E, Mathias L
- Respondents: CAcert
Initial Case Manager: UlrichSchroeter
Case Manager: Mario Lipinski
Arbitrator: UlrichSchroeter
- Date of arbitration start: 2010-12-04
- Date of ruling: 2010-12-04
- Case closed: 2010-12-13
- Complaint: Wrong Name
- Relief: TBD
Before: Arbitrator UlrichSchroeter (A), Respondent: CAcert (R) Claimant: Michael T (C1), Andreas A (C2) Dominik G (C3) Bjoern E (C4), Mathias L (C5) Case: a20100314.1
History Log
- 2010-03-14 (issue.c.o) case [s20100314.5]
2010-03-14 (UlrichSchroeter): added to wiki, request for CM / A
- 2010-03-14 (C): accepts CCA / DRP under this arbitration (from within dispute filing)
- (from case a20100320.1)
- 2010-03-18 (issue.c.o) case [s20100318.7], encrypted mail unreadable to Support
- 2010-03-19 (Support): please resend dispute filing unencrypted
2010-03-20 (issue.c.o) case [s20100318.7] from C (C2)
- 2010-03-22 (iCM): added to wiki, request for CM / A
2010-03-22 (issue.c.o) case [s20100322.70] from C2 (C3)
- 2010-03-22 (iCM) [s20100322.70] merged to this case
2010-03-22 (issue.c.o) case [s20100322.142] from C3 (C4)
- 2010-03-24 (iCM): [s20100322.142] merged to this case
2010-04-06 (C1): If I guess right Arbitration a20100314.1 should be merged with a20100320.1. Just to save you some work, one A and CM less to find
- 2010-04-06 (iCM): added info from (C1) to this case, later on to decide by (CM) and (A) to merge both cases. Account in question is the same in both cases.
- 2010-11-27 (A): I'll take care about this case as (A)
- 2010-11-27 (CM): I'll take care about this case as (CM)
- 2010-11-29 (C2): accepts CCA/DRP and sends his PoV
- 2010-12-04 (A): reminder about CCA / DRP acceptance to (C5)
- 2010-12-04 (C5): accepts CCA/DRP
Intermediate Ruling
I hereby order to merge Arbitration case a20100320.1 to this arbitration case, as respondent to be identical, dispute filing was identical (problem with name in users online account), now to be handled under a20100314.1.
Infos from dispute filing case a20100320.1 should be transfered to this case a20100314.1.
Arbitration case a20100320.1 to be closed immediately
Frankfurt/Main, 2010-11-27
Discovery
- 2010-03-22 (R): states himself typo in his online account first givenname, so moving to claimants list (C5)
- 2010-03-14 (C1): accepts CCA/DRP within dispute filing
- Typo on first givenname
Claimant
Name
CCA/DRP accepted
Conforms to name change request
note
C1
Michael T
{+}
{+}
C2
Andreas A
{+}
{+}
C3
Dominik G
{+}
revoke assurance
C4
Bjoern E
{+}
revoke assurance
C5
Mathias L
{+}
{+}
- 2010-03-18 (C2): states, that account has allready 70 assurance points
2010-12-04 (C3): CCA/DRP acceptance confirmed under a20100223.1
2010-12-04 (C4): CCA/DRP acceptance confirmed under a20100304.1
Ruling
- There is enough evidance over the requested givenname (to be a typo), at least confirmed by four assurers and (C) according to AP 2.1
- there was no malfeasance of an type alleged or found
- So therefor I hereby order, that the Givenname in Users account should be changed as requested
- Certificates issued after 2009-11-08 (date when CPS became draft) that include the not corrected givenname have to be revoked by the user
Frankfurt/Main, 2010-12-04
Execution
- 2010-12-04 (A): Ruling sent to (C1), (C2), (C3), (C4), (C5), (Support)
- 2010-12-04 (A): ruling exec request to (Support) with exec report request
- 2010-12-04 (A): certs revocation request to (C5) following the ruling, or confirmation statement, that no certs exists by users CARS statement
- 2010-12-04 (C5): confirms, there still exists no client certs issued after 2009-11-08 that contains the wrong givenname in name field
- 2010-12-10 (Support): [s20101204.39] reports, name changed as requested and ordered.
- 2010-12-13 (A): exec notification to (C1), (C2), (C3), (C4), (C5), (CM) sent. Case closed.
Similiar Cases